In 1974, a family of six was brutally murdered. A year later, George and Kathy Lutz and their children move into the site of the horrific event, which is haunted by a murderous presence.

Casey, a vice president of her father's company, has nobody in her life. But one night, she meets three eligible bachelors: a preppy old friend, a star quarterback, and a waiter / musician. With the help of her (horny) friend, she must decide the outcome of the dating game.