Andy Miller has asked a large number of women he didn't know to marry him. They said no. But Emma, a beautiful veterinary student agrees to go on some dates to see if they'll fall in love. Emma thinks this is all a joke set up by her roommate Mandy, but it's all a reality TV show created by Andy and Emma's the oblivious star.

Truman has loved Beth for as long as he can remember. But she's the hot girl, and he's the kind of guy the jocks shove into lockers. He enlists the help of his good but reluctant friend Ari to pose as his girlfriend to make Beth jealous.