A man's life is upended by increasingly threatening phone calls demanding he leave a review for a paperweight purchased online.

Two life-long friends, both professional ministers, face similar crisis of faith and struggle to rediscover God's grace in the midst of their individual failures.

Heather's happy life is interrupted by the news her long ago ex-girlfriend, Catalonia has passed away. She is asked to travel to Bishop's Cove, the small upstate New York town Cat grew up in to deliver the ashes to Cat's mother, father, and sister. While there, Heather will be confronted by demons both personal and, in the form of The Nameless. Now, more than Heather's perfect life is in danger. Her soul is too.

Marion Knapp, a comedian hanging on between the end of his career and the end of his life, finds a chance at redemption when he's offered a fortune to speak at the funeral of a mysterious benefactor.